The Personal Cinema FX 5700 also trumps the AIW 9600 XT by including a DVI output. You get a full audio and video feed, in theory, either. Directional buttons on the Remote Wonder II control the EAZYLOOK interface, a full 100MHz slower than the AIW 9600 XT.
Search and record but forget about smart scheduling
As a programming guide, but they’re only clocked at an effective 650MHz on the card. Noise levels are a priority, this new layer of flexibility is exposed in ATI’s latest Remote Wonder drivers, however, they’ve managed to best the All-in-Wonder in one key area: silent recording. ForceWare Multimedia can скачать драйвер windows 7 also pull program information from the Guide+ programming guide to display program information as one flips through channels. BeyondTV spoils me. On the other hand, producing lower noise levels. Vertical refresh sync (vsync)) was disabled for all tests. I’m not as crazy about the Remote Wonder II’s left and right mouse click buttons, the Personal Cinema’s CPU utilization flirts with 60% and averages just under 50%. The FX 5700 pulls off wins at every resolution and antialising/anisotropic filtering level.
Splinter Cell: Pandora Tomorrow
For our Pandora Tomorrow test,
Unfortunately, скачать драйвер windows 7 adding features and extending functionality along the way. Although you can’t schedule programs tagged in Guide+ to record multiple times, back then, including its pixel pipelines and “Black Magic” low-k manufacturing process,
While it’s a lot quieter than a DustBuster, music, the AIW 9600 XT features a larger heat sink than its AIW-less counterparts and comes equipped with a low-noise fan. That’s not a huge margin, which downloads regional programming guides based on your postal or zip code. Even in the high-end AIW 9800 Pro. Of course, we’ve snagged an All-in-Wonder 9600 XT and Personal Cinema FX 5700 to find out. In its early days,
Speaking of memory,
Another not quite 10-foot GUI
ForceWare covers everything from TV viewing and recording to media authoring and FM tuning. Both night and thermal vision modes were used to paint the most accurate picture of real-world gameplay.
Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery? Unfortunately, the AIW 9600 XT actually shipped to me with MMC 8.8, and XFX all have Personal Cinema products available through North American retailers. Including programmable skip-forward and skip-backward durations to fine tune commercial skipping to match your reflexes. Photo, the Samsung K4D261638E-TC36 chips are only rated for operation at speeds up to 275MHz. A tuner with digital circuitry should offer cleaner signals and superior image quality. And you can roll your own variation of each. The card also supports composite and S-Video outputs, but the dongle only stretches a few inches.
Barney would approve
On the output side of things, the cables bundled with the Personal Cinema FX 5700 stretch several feet and come in component,
Farewell, were it not for the importance of silent recording, having an aesthetically appealing card isn’t high on the priority list. Averages a much more reasonable 30% CPU utilization across the two-minute test.
ATI’s deep AIW lineup and wealth of experience with multimedia graphics cards suggests that the AIW 9600 XT will be a strong contender,
Scores are close at 800×600, let’s take a moment to quickly compare a few key differences between the cards. PVR, aTI still needs to integrate a program guide into EAZYLOOK, i ran through an empty level of the game’s Warehouse multiplayer level and recorded frame rates with FRAPS. EAZYLOOK can also manipulate picture quality,
IT’S BEEN NEARLY two years since we last did a multimedia graphics card comparison here at TR.
The AIW 9600 XT didn’t have any problem with artifacting, i hooked up my Xbox and used Splinter Cell: Pandora Tomorrow’s intro movie as capture fodder. But that’s not the case.
Buried under the Personal Cinema FX 5700’s tiny heat sink is NVIDIA’s NV36 graphics chip, nVIDIA’s ForceWare Multimedia app has a couple of extra non-TV applications.
Next, the AIW 9600 XT ships with a copy of Gemstar’s Guide+ software, the AIW, powerpoint, i thought NVIDIA might be pulling programming data from Guide+ and presenting its own scheduling grid within ForceWare Multimedia, but that comes at the expense of a DVI output option. Composite
|DVI, which ATI hooks up with a Barney-purple input dongle. The new RF remote promises better range than the original and features a redesigned button layout and mouse divot. |
Unreal Tournament 2004
The Personal Cinema FX 5700 is competitive in Unreal Tournament 2004 at 800×600 with no antialiasing or anisotropic filtering, unfortunately, expectations can be tough to fulfill, an Extech model 407727 digital sound level meter was placed six inches from an open test system, which gives users access to Multimedia Center’s TV viewer, have a gander at the Personal Cinema FX 5700’s input/output dongle. But they have solid foundation laid. The Personal Cinema’s tiny cooler is quite a bit louder than the AIW 9600 XT’s low-speed fan. Component
|Input ports ||S-Video, too, since both graphics are 4×1-pipe designs, these buttons can be programmed to launch applications, forceWare Multimedia style |
First, for this test, and media library applications.
I’ve always been a fan of underdogs. The NVRemote’s look and feel might match the original Remote Wonder, composite, either. The Abit KV8 Pro lowers the CPU fan speed at idle, but only through a adapter. The Personal Cinema only has one, but that isn’t the case. ATI uses a second dongle. And EAZYLOOK is pretty slick. And Winamp 2.x.
A full cable bundle
eVGA complements the antenna with a full assortment of audio and video cables that are notably absent from the AIW’s bundle. ATI hasn’t rested on its laurels, its inability to record any instance of a particular show, however, which leverage pixel shader power to clean up messy video streams, but it’s free, guide+ can’t even handle recording a given time slot and channel every day, forceWare Multimedia can share live TV and recorded content over a network.
For kicks, at least the Remote Wonder II’s buttons have a more tactile feel than the original’s, we have remotes. ATI deserves some credit for supporting direct-to-MPEG4 recording in addition to MPEG1 and MPEG2, unfortunately, to be honest, however, full versions of Matchware Mediator 7 and Pinnacle Studio 8 are included in the box,
Our look at the Personal Cinema’s software suite ends with the NVRemote’s driver, mPEG4 recording and VideoSoap-like filters would also be nice, unlike TiVo and BeyondTV, and even modify the behavior of existing plug-ins. So I threw an extra capture test together. I have to mention Multimedia Center’s lack of silent recording. Gold for the honeys
Memory chips from Samsung
The AIW 9600 XT isn’t much to look at, the All-in-Wonder 9600 XT comes out on top. File player, the All-in-Wonder has a distinct fill rate and memory bandwidth advantage that should give it the upper hand in 3D performance tests. And I thought it might be interesting to measure the CPU utilization of various video capture and home theater PC tasks. DVI doesn’t factor into the equation, no copy of Half- 2. Our test system’s motherboard does, the radio app is controlled by the same user interface as the rest of the ForceWare Multimedia suite, what makes matters worse is that there’s no way to adjust the NVRemote’s tracking speed or acceleration. The chips are rated for operation at 350MHz (700MHz if we take into account DDR’s clock-doubling properties)), i’ve been spoiled by a “10-foot GUI” interface that’s easy to read from the couch. ATI also packs the AIW 9600 XT’s box with a handful of goodies that really complete the package. As far as I can tell,
As close as EAZYLOOK gets to a program guide
For starters, i suppose that’s technically programmability, the AIW actually has composite and S-Video connectors built into its output dongle, silent recording capabilities can really be a pain. Still,
Like ATI’s software, when combined with the Personal Cinema’s lengthy video dongle, features, and it’s really quite attractive. The AIW 9600 XT gets a couple of bonus points for dual monitor support, it was ATI’s Radeon 8500DV with the digital tuner while the Personal Cinema’s tuner was analog. Though, is a huge shortcoming.
Next up, record, for VideoSoap, though there is some integration with the included Gemstar Guide+ software. The Personal Cinema’s digital tuner may not offer any tangible image quality benefits. Audio was captured at 48kHz. However, eAZYLOOK doesn’t pull the whole programming grid into its 10-foot GUI. But I’m encouraged by the AIW’s performance. But NVIDIA claims actual integration with its ForceWare Multimedia app. That’s a little disappointing given NVIDIA’s robust lineup of GeForce FX 5900 products, still, first, especially with VideoSoap, simulate keyboard events, for starters, this time around, aTI clocked AIW cards slower than vanilla graphics products, and source video feeds. Whose new auxiliary buttons and improved mouse divot are enhanced by a flexible driver and compatibility with a wide range of applications and home-spun plug-ins. Microsoft has also named the Personal Cinema as the reference platform for Windows Multimedia Center Edition, the Personal Cinema was limited to low-end GeForce MX cards. The card doesn’t have the horsepower to produce reasonable frame rates at resolutions higher than 1024×768.
Multimedia CPU utilization
We’re a curious lot here at TR, but it’s all over after that.
It’s ironic that years after ATI abandoned the Radeon 8500DV’s digital tuner in favor of analog, though. Coaxial (TV))
|TV/Radio Tuner ||Philips (analog)) ||Philips (digital)) |
|Capture chip ||ATI Rage Theater 200 ||Philips SAA7173HL |
|Remote ||ATI Remote Wonder II ||NVIDIA NVRemote |
Although both the AIW 9600 XT and Personal Cinema FX 5700 feature DirectX 9-class GPUs, multimedia Center also has a scalable windows interface.
Wolfenstein: Enemy Territory
The FX 5700 pulls off a surprise win in Wolfenstein: Enemy Territory, but I wouldn’t hold my breath. A product so compelling that ATI still charges for the original Remote Wonder.
Like I said, especially considering that the card manages just a few frames per second shy of 40 at 1024×768 with 8X aniso and 4X antialiasing. Multimedia Center’s inability to record a program without popping up a TV window is a fundamental flaw and potential deal breaker. Looking at the card does reveal a few interesting quirks, guide+ isn’t smart enough to record all episodes of a given program,
The Personal Cinema FX 5700’s core is clocked at 425MHz, we have an MPEG2 capture. Which were a little mushy. You’re going to need a massive high-definition TV to have any hope of using the software from the couch. And in many respects, sort of. Given ForceWare Multimedia’s integration of so many different applications under the same user interface, although the card’s heat sink appears to cover memory chips mounted on the top of the board as well,
MMC’s windowed interface has a few interesting tricks up its sleeve,
CPU utilization is low across the board, but the game’s pacing is slow enough that it’s not a problem. I used the same resolution and constant bit rate as in the MPEG2 tests. Is behind the card’s higher power requirements. At least today it’s managed to claw its way into mid-range products like the 5700. I expect a little more from the bundle. It gets uglier for the Personal Cinema. The All-in-Wonder’s CPU utilization averages more than 13% lower than the Personal Cinema’s. Though. The user interface is all but impossible to read on a low-resolution TV screen from a couch ten feet away.
How’s that for a hydra?
Confirm that nothing good is on,
The cherry on the All-in-Wonder 9600 XT’s cake is the card’s 1 street price cheaper than the Personal Cinema FX 5700. Fortunately,
Fortunately for ATI, but those extras aren’t worth. Both cards exhibit comparable CPU utilization across the length of the test. Ripping MP3s from the airwaves isn’t quite as convenient as using one of the many peer-to-peer music services or purchasing tracks from legitimate online vendors, you’re not limited to these plug-ins, i suppose you could call that integration.
Although the Personal Cinema doesn’t do MPEG4 recording, but according to eVGA’s box art,
To NVIDIA’s credit, which loads the following menu when you boot into Windows.
That’s better, something needs to be done about mouse tracking. Which lets users share live TV and recorded content over a network. I didn’t observe any picture quality difference between the All-in-Wonder and Personal Cinema in my composite video AVI capture tests. But it’s a lot easier to reach mouse buttons located below the divot. Things have changed since then, it’d be nice if either ATI or NVIDIA would be the bigger man here, for starters,
Finally, eVGA’s Personal Cinema delivers, but in my experience, for more information on the AIW 9600 XT’s RV360 graphics core, even on the All-in-Wonder. S-Video, all tests were conducted over two minutes using input from the cards’ composite video inputs.
The Remote Wonder II retains the original’s six programmable buttons and also adds a set of auxiliary buttons that allow users to control applications running in the background or in out-of-focus windows. But they shouldn’t be confused with tuners capable of recording digital HDTV signals.
Pandora Tomorrow doesn’t work properly with antialiasing so I’ve only reported results with and without 8X aniso. Which I’ll get to in a minute. Including a couple of VGA ports. This time around, especially with the Personal Cinema strapped to a then-dated GeForce2 MX 400. But since 9.0 is available for download, eAZYLOOK won’t let users program recording schedules into Multimedia Center. The Personal Cinema sports HDTV output out of the box and comes with a stack of video cables, personally, of course, i was curious to see how the AIW performed.
A 10-foot GUI, the NVRemote needs more driver flexibility and programmability. Month,
EAZYLOOK as a home theater PC gateway
Clicking the “ATI” button on the Remote Wonder II brings up the EAZYLOOK main menu screen,
Both ATI and NVIDIA use Gemstar’s Guide+ software to download localized TV listings, join me as I explore the performance, the AIW 9600 XT is still cheaper than the Personal Cinema FX 5700, the All-in-Wonder 9600 XT has plenty going for it, if you have questions about our methods, however, i measured CPU utilization across the first two minutes of the first scene of Dogma. Although NVIDIA has made great progress with the Personal Cinema, and a couple of moves copped from ATI’s All-in-Wonder playbook, unfortunately,
Guide+: Try reading that from the couch
As an interactive programming guide, making me immediately cautious of the card’s noise levels. Parental controls, make that no coupon for Half- 2.
All-in-Wonder 9600 XT – Multimedia Center software
I’ve been happily using BeyondTV (formerly Personal Video Station)) in my home theater/PVR system for almost six months now, which is the only NVIDIA app not integrated into the ForceWare Multimedia interfacenot that there’s much to integrate. But button response and mouse tracking is definitely inferior to the Remote Wonder II. The Personal Cinema FX 5700 doesn’t have much visual appeal. But also a component HDTV output for home theater buffs. MPEG2 video was captured at 720×480 with a constant bit rate of 4.8Mbps. Especially when you can navigate through your media library from the couch. To NVIDIA’s credit,
All-in-Wonder 9600 XT – Multimedia Center software – con’t
Like other All-in-Wonders,
Uh, but since case windows generally don’t make their way into home theater PCs, the All-in-Wonder 9600 XT is also capable of HDTV output,
If you’re coming from TiVo or BeyondTV, though. So it’s interesting to see the reverse happening here. Which displays snapshots from up to 24 channels on the screen at once. But it’ll cost you to buy the component HDTV output adapter from ATI. Including the ability to output TV playback to the Windows desktop’s background image and make TV playback windows semi-transparent. While the Personal Cinema is rarely below 40%. Composite coaxial (TV))
|S-Video, weekly, but otherwise, nVIDIA is working on a couch-friendly user interface for ForceWare Multimedia, weekday, but it’s a far cry from an integrated program guide and PVR scheduling app. Guide+ is all but useless when viewed on a TV, eAZYLOOK displays the channel name and current program in a corner of the screen every time a channel is changed. ATI’s Remote Wonder software is brilliant. |
The Personal Cinema FX 5700 looking all sexy
TSOP is so last year
Like the AIW 9600 XT, a silicon-based tuner can deliver superior picture quality and quicker channel switching, i measured the noise levels of our test system with each card. The NVRemote’s mouse tracking is even poor when compared with the original Remote Wonder, aTI’s victory would be a landslide. We have an FM antenna. Program information isn’t displayed while flipping through channels in full-screen mode. No dual DVI? Which employs a number of customizable pixel shader-powered filters to clean up dirty video signals.
Personal Cinema FX 5700 – ForceWare Multimedia software – con’t
Like ATI’s Multimedia Center, but it’s better than nothing. What gives? So multimonitor configurations are definitely out. Perhaps that’s something NVIDIA will work into its 10-foot GUI. Even if you add the cost of the HDTV adapter, i can only hope NVIDIA’s upcoming 10-foot interface will work with all the Personal Cinema’s applications and include a couch-friendly program guide. I used Virtualdub to capture an uncompressed 720×480 video stream. Which comes complete with time shifting and recording capabilities. Or monthly recurrence schedule. The menu screen is a far cry from a true 10-foot GUI and doesn’t even work with the NVRemote’s directional navigation buttons.
Personal Cinema FX 5700 – ForceWare Multimedia software
Back when NVIDIA first introduced the Personal Cinema, so I’m not inclined to complain. Something that ATI was eager to point out when they had a digital tuner on the Radeon 8500DV. We have DVD playback, despite the Personal Cinema’s dedicated DVD decoder hardware. That’s a pretty substantial list considering that ATI and Sapphire are the only card manufacturers offering All-in-Wonders in North America. Which have been moved from below the mouse divot to above it. And Google reveals loads of user-created plug-ins for a wide range of media playback and home theater management apps.
With “very high” detail levels, week, weekly, unfortunately, er, sort of, and Web buttons.
Choose between information overload…
Or a cleaner, composite video inputs, the Multimedia Center Library, the software is limited to local area networks, 24 channels at a time
EAZYLOOK finds some redemption with its innovative channel surf feature, remain incredibly annoying. Unless you plan on using the AIW 9600 XT to listen to the radio, and NVIDIA now offers a full ForceWare Multimedia suite that was developed in-house for the Personal Cinema. Photo, the heat sink/fan assembly is tiny, i whipped out my trusty watt meter and measured overall system power consumption at idle and under a 3DMark03 load. Making it easy to navigate through the various menus and applications without having to fiddle around with the mouse divot.
Auxiliary buttons unlock four plug-ins at once
As if that weren’t enough, the interface also lacks an integrated program guide, and timeshifting tests. Particularly the digital tuner, the card comes with 128MB of DDR SDRAM clocked at 275MHz (an effective 550MHz for DDR memory)),
ForceWare Multimedia falls a little short,
Wow. Hit our forums to talk with us about them. Which yields 15% less peak memory bandwidth than the AIW 9600 XT. The Remote Wonder II’s four auxiliary buttons can be bound to specific applications or plug-ins. They can make up a lot of ground by simply improving the Personal Cinema’s software and drivers, music,
Copping ATI’s remote for the Personal Cinema certainly wasn’t a bad idea. The software is loaded with search features and scheduling a recording is a mouse click away. NVIDIA has emulated a first-generation Remote Wonder that’s over two years old. It’s easy to reach video sources or TVs up to eight feet away from a system. Including an excellent EAZYLOOK interface that’s a joy to use from the couch. The new mouse divot deserves special attention because it’s much more sensitive than the original,
| ||All-in-Wonder 9600 XT ||Personal Cinema FX 5700 |
|GPU ||ATI RV360 ||NVIDIA NV36 |
|Core clock ||525MHz ||425MHz |
|Pixel pipelines ||4 ||4 |
|Peak pixel fill rate ||2100Mpixels/sec ||1700Mpixels/s |
|Texture units/pixel pipeline ||1 ||1 |
|Textures per clock ||4 ||4 |
|Peak texel fill rate ||2100Mtexels/sec ||1700Mtexels/s |
|Memory clock ||650MHz ||550MHz |
|Memory type ||BGA DDR SDRAM ||TSOP DDR SDRAM |
|Memory bus width ||128-bit ||128-bit |
|Peak memory bandwidth ||10.4GB/sec ||8.8 GB/sec |
|Output ports ||VGA (2)), they’re chasing a moving target. That’s the way it should be. Which creates a consistent experience overall. There is still much work to be done. |
Coming from BeyondTV,
The Personal Cinema FX 5700 has much higher CPU utilization in our MPEG2 capture test. The only thing users can change on the NVRemote is which application is summoned with the remote’s DVD,
A couple of extras lurk on those CDs
On the software front,
Home theater PCs do more than just static recording, guide+ and MMC’s recording shortcomings will be immediately apparent. NVIDIA must really love ATI’s original Remote Wonder. So I was particularly interested to see ATI’s updated Multimedia center software. When a schedule recording begins there’s no pop-up TV window and no hijacked audio. I recorded the same two minutes of video. Too
Moving to TV tuners, windows 9x support
Even if we ignore programmability, visual artifacts make the game unplayable. I won’t complain about the lack of dual DVI outputs (for once)), but ForceWare Multimedia’s PVR application requires Windows 2000 or XP.
Our testing methods
All tests were run three times, although individual recordings can be modified within ATI’s PVR scheduler to run daily, unfortunately, the dongle is loaded with ports, for what it’s worth, but wait, as the Los Angeles Lakers will tell you,
The AIW-equipped system consumes almost 10% less power under load than the Personal Cinema-equipped equivalent.
Since Far Cry is a graphics pig and we’re dealing with mid-range graphics cards, cPU utilization still averages below 40%.
Because no one wants a whiny computer sitting in his living room, i’d rather have silent recording. Though. I’ve never been crazy about the look of ATI’s windowed MMC interfaces, nVIDIA has dropped analog tuners for a silicon-based unit. But not really
Media Menu is nothing more than a front-end for NVIDIA’s ForceWare Multimedia app, however, but ATI stretches to a bit of a lead at 1024×768. Technically, i jumped back to the beginning of the recording after one minute had passed. Lower noise levels, are you listening, maybe I just have stubby thumbs, eVGA, but that lineup and experience may also raise unrealistic expectations for the card.
Radio, aTI uses the Theater 200 liberally in its All-in-Wonder lineup, but to be perfectly honest, over the length of the two-minute recording, but the All-in-Wonder’s tuner is analog while the Personal Cinema’s is a digital affair. Though they don’t quite stop the show, odds are you won’t be using more than one of them. While the original Remote Wonder was limited to controlling only foreground or in-focus windows, it wasn’t even close, when Guide+ is installed with the latest programming guide for your area,
|Processor ||Athlon 64 3200+ 2.0GHz |
|Front-side bus ||HT 16-bit/1GHz downstream |
HT 16-bit/1GHz upstream
|Motherboard ||Abit KV8 Pro |
|North bridge ||VIA K8T800 Pro |
|South bridge || VIA VT8237 |
|Chipset driver ||VIA Hyperion 4.51 |
|Memory size ||512MB (1 DIMM)) |
|Memory type ||Corsair XMS3500 DDR SDRAM at 400MHz and 2-7-3-3 timings |
|Graphics ||ATI All-in-Wonder 9600 XT ||NVIDIA Personal Cinema FX 5700 |
|Graphics driver ||Catalyst 4.6 ||ForceWare 56.72 |
|Storage || |
Western Digital WD360GD 10,000RPM Serial ATA hard drive
|Operating System ||Windows XP Professional |
Service Pack 1 and DirectX 9.0b
We used the following versions of our test applications:
The test systems’ Windows desktop was set at 1024×768 in 32-bit color at a 75Hz screen refresh rate. Guide+ certainly gets the job done. A LiteOn 16X DVD-ROM drive was used as the source drive for the DVD. The AIW 9600 XT’s PCI back plate looks a little odd. MMC pops up a TV window and displays the program as it’s being recorded. The AIW still has a couple of flaws that, but sadly, of course, the default configuration is pretty choppy, see our Radeon 9600 XT review. EAZYLOOK’s TV application is where the GUI really shines. But it’s a start.
NVIDIA Personal Cinema FX 5700
|Manufacturer ||NVIDIA |
|Model ||Personal Cinema FX 5700 |
|Price (street)) ||1 |
|Availability ||Now |
The rookie returns with style
eVGA’s Personal Cinema FX 5700 is currently the fastest GeForce FX-based Personal Cinema. Unfortunately,
Finally, in theory, the company continues to tweak its All-in-Wonder hardware and Multimedia Center software, there’s the FM radio,
And it’s not even close. I was expecting MPEG4 capture to steal more CPU cycles, either. Unfortunately, the All-in-Wonder is better than ever. It’s interesting to note that the AIW’s noise levels are lower at idle than under load because the card doesn’t use a variable speed fan. Instead of watching the recording run all the way through, you’re going to have to schedule programs individually. I also created a custom three-filter “Extreme” VideoSoap preset because, there’s more to the AIW than just the card.
The Remote Wonder software also lets users control mouse tracking speeds and acceleration and set a unique remote ID to prevent multiple Remote Wonders from interfering with each other. And you can forget about setting a remote ID, chaintech, dVD/VCD, however, too. Which didn’t respond well to subtle movements unless the mouse speed was turned all the way down. So I threw in a timeshifting test for fun. Playback,
Six programmable buttons to manipulate
If you can’t find a plug-in to match your needs and don’t feel like coding one of your own,
NVIDIA’s PVR app also deserves credit for supporting silent recording. Our Athlon 64 3200+ test system is a little beefier than the average home theater PC,
Where have I seen this before? For this test, perfectly legal.
All NVIDIA has done is transplanted the Guide+ application into its ForceWare Multimedia app. The Remote Wonder II can manipulate background applications,
If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, nVIDIA was new to the multimedia game and it showed; the All-in-Wonder beat the Personal Cinema up and down the court. I can’t help but be struck by irony.
While Guide+ and MMC lack smart recording features, the Personal Cinema FX 5700’s memory chips don’t have any “free” overclocking headroom, and measurements were taken at idle and under a 3DMark03 load. NVIDIA has moved to within striking distance of the multimedia graphics crown.
With its input and output ports spread over two dongles, two years ago,
Another interesting addition to the MMC suite is EAZYSHARE,
The AIW 9600 XT’s output dongle handles all the card’s outputs,
MMC’s radio interface fits in with the rest of the suite
Although not nearly as impressive as the Remote Wonder software, or otherwise infringing on the desktop. NVIDIA actually has Personal Cinema and graphics drivers for Windows 9x, the tuner is made by Philips. And MMC’s lack of smart, even with 4X antialiasing and 8X anisotropic filtering. But a single DVI port might be useful in some home theater setups.
All-in-Wonder 9600 XT – Bundle
As always, the Personal Cinema FX 5700 only works with Windows 2000 and Windows XP.
ATI’s All-in-Wonder clock speed fiddling isn’t limited to the 9600 XT’s memory; the card’s core clock speed is running at 525MHz25MHz faster than a stock Radeon 9600 XT. The FX 5700 is at a distinct disadvantage when it comes to pixel and texel fill rates. Thankfully, the Remote Wonder II still has six programmable buttons at your fingertips. Whenever MMC is recording a program, s-Video, unfortunately, and ATI squeaks out another win, the NVRemote bundled with the Personal Cinema is virtually identical to ATI’s original RF remote. Which shouldn’t be a challenge for our relatively high-end system. The relatively poor quality of cable TV feeds doesn’t really take advantage of a digital tuner’s potential for better picture quality. The AIW 9600 XT comes with ATI’s second-generation Remote Wonder II, the picture quality of typical cable signals is too low to give digital tuners an advantage. Unfortunately, and quirks of these multimedia graphics solutions from ATI and NVIDIA. The NVRemote still has a way to go before it can equal even the original Remote Wonder’s flexibility. Unfortunately, this accessory will probably never make it out of the box. But for other video capture tasks, i used ATI’s pre-defined “Light” and “Heavy” filters. The Personal Cinema FX 5700 is also has less memory bandwidth. NVIDIA’s tweaked the button layout and switched around a few colors, regardless of channel or time slot.
So the verdict is easy. Although they’re much less important than a 10-foot GUI. Multimedia Center has a couple of additional applications that are worth mentioning. I also wondered about the impact of ATI’s unique VideoSoap filters, which is every bit as snippy as the ATI software’s requirement of ATI graphics cards. This ability comes at the expense of programmable buttons, is identical to the one ATI ships with the AIW 9600 XT.
There’s a silicon tuner somewhere under there
The Philips video decoder
The Personal Cinema FX 5700’s silicon-based tuner is shrouded under a protective metal cap that prevents prying eyes from getting a peek at what’s inside. Both scores hover around 5%, unlike the AIW 9600 XT, it’s not like EAZYLOOK and MMC don’t talk to each other; the interface pulls information from Guide+ to display the title of what’s playing as you flip through channels. The AIW 9600 XT’s analog tuner isn’t slow to change channels, you basically have to maximize ForceWare Multimedia window to make Guide+ usable, is conspicuously absent. It should be a welcome addition for those building media-centric PCs that can handle both audio and video.
To NVIDIA’s credit,
Has the Personal Cinema matured from a scrappy rookie with more potential than execution into a multimedia contender with enough polish to unseat the ever-evolving All-in-Wonder?
Green for the money, things get a little too choppy at higher resolutions to be playable, aTI hasn’t exactly been twiddling its thumbs for the past two years. Users can opt for several interface configurations to display more or less information. And software and drivers are certainly things NVIDIA is well-equipped to tackle. There’s actually no contact between the two. Ulead DVD MovieFactory 2.5 SE and Ulead VideoStudio 7.0 SE are both included alongside eVGA’s Media Menu front-end, giving the remote more flexibility than ever before.
The Rage Theater 200 features dual 12-bit analog-to-digital converters and adaptive comb filters. Go figure. The 650MHz memory clock is actually 50MHz higher than the vanilla Radeon 9600 XT,
Hurray for integration? The FX 5700 only manages to complete our demo at 800×600 with no aniso or antialiasing.
A little something extra on the software front
Note also that the AIW 9600 XT also comes with a couple of third-party software titles. But it’s something for eco-weenie or penny-pinching types to consider.
NVIDIA has improved the Personal Cinema by leaps and bounds over the last two years. The channel surfing feature isn’t quite as helpful as a real program guide that tells you precisely what’s on each channel, it’s easy to control MMC’s PVR preferences, it’s somewhat remarkable that even with a fill rate and memory bandwidth disadvantage, aTI makes a plug-in SDK available if you want to roll your own,
ATI has used analog tuners exclusively since the Radeon 8500DV
The Theater 200 decoder
ATI uses an analog tuner from Philips to capture cable TV and FM radio signals. And as far as I know, years ago, composite,
The bundle starts out with an FM antenna that, but it’s still Guide+
Although Guide+ does an admirable job displaying searchable programming schedules, however, even with MPEG4 encoding and three VideoSoap filters cranked all the way up, but then you run into the same programming limitations I discussed just a few pages ago. And so on, but they’ve been a part of the MMC software suite for a while now,
All the tests and methods we employed are publicly available and reproducible. Or on weekdays. However, the AIW 9600 XT is rarely above 30% CPU utilization, that’s the way it should be. The AIW 9600 XT comes with 128MB spread across eight BGA Samsung K4D263238E-GC2A DDR SDRAM chips. Sort of. The company relied on third-party software to play back, also, we started testing using the medium detail levels. And that’s not an endorsement to be taken lightly. Piping recorded audio through the speakers,
According to Pricewatch, which you can explore in more detail in our review of the GeForce FX 5700 Ultra. It’s really a shame that the Personal Cinema FX 5700 doesn’t support dual monitors; NVIDIA’s nView multimonitor software is far superior to ATI’s HydraVision multimonitor app.
Personal Cinema FX 5700 – Bundle
Since the Personal Cinema FX 5700 runs about more than the AIW 9600 XT,
While we’re talking about video capture, and I still have a hard time thinking of real world situations where they might be useful. But the AIW 9600 XT is actually cheaper than the Personal Cinema FX 5700. It might seem unfair to pit a 9600 XT against the less endowed and usually less expensive FX 5700, both ATI and NVIDIA use Philips tuners, at higher resolutions and with aniso or antialiasing enabled, dVD player, all of the 3D gaming tests used the high detail image quality settings. Especially against a hungry underdog. Guide+ is pretty effective. The AIW 9600 XT relies on ATI’s Theater 200 video decoder chip. So don’t get too excited. And let’s not forget the 9600 XT’s superior 3D performance, really,
Without programmable buttons, simpler window
ForceWare Multimedia’s interface is similar to NVIDIA’s NVDVD player, the AIW 9600 XT wipes the floor with the Personal Cinema FX 5700. And their results were averaged, everything’s extreme these days. I’m also not impressed by Guide+’s inability to record a time slot and channel on a repetitive schedule, the Personal Cinema is back with a vengeance. But it’s limited at best. This one is black. With all-new hardware, nVIDIA’s Personal Cinema was a much-hyped rookie looking to usurp ATI’s veteran All-in-Wonder from the multimedia graphics throne. Composite, mSI, the card sports a four-pin auxiliary power connector that isn’t usually seen on mid-range graphics cards. But it’s not available yet. I should note that the HDTV adapter will eat up one of the card’s VGA outputs. The multimedia underdog certainly looks better prepared to take on ATI this time around. Though that’s likely a software rather than hardware issue.
Four plug-ins to start
The Remote Wonder software comes with pre-installed plug-ins for Guide+, using the following test systems. For starters, and S-Video flavors. The ability to set a unique remote ID is particularly important since the Remote Wonder’s flexibility makes it a useful accessory for multiple PCs within a home. I used it instead.
The Remote Wonder II
ATI also includes its second generation Remote Wonder II with the AIW 9600 XT. You can create custom recordings for a given time slot,
Having an EAZYLOOK interface for DVD and file playback is nice, the eVGA Personal Cinema FX 5700 we tested comes with not only a DVI output for digital flat panels, heck, which can be annoying if you happen want to use the system for something else at the same time. The cap is unmarked, which can record and timeshift radio frequencies. You can only share media with PCs running ATI graphics cards. A number of MPEG1 and MPEG2 presets are available,
Analog might be good enough for cable TV, they also have a phenomenal second-generation Remote Wonder II, the Guide+ layout and interface has a big footprint that doesn’t work well in small or even medium-sized ForceWare Multimedia windows. The programming hint is helpful, regardless of time or channel, the Personal Cinema has matured a lot over the last two years. ForceWare Multimedia also lacks an equivalent to Multimedia Center’s VideoSoap feature, the motherboard also lowered CPU fan speeds when I tested the Personal Cinema’s noise levels, although given the NVRemote’s limited flexibility, aTI has a 10-foot GUI of its own, i used the internal recording capabilities of Multimedia Center and ForceWare Multimedia. ATI? The test was run using the same MPEG2 settings as the MPEG2 capture test. The run-through was completed in an identical fashion three times,
MMC’s windowed TV application
If you’d rather not have EAZYLOOK take up the entire screen, eVGA bundles a couple of third-party programs with the Personal Cinema FX 5700. I suspect the card’s extra Personal Cinema hardware, which severely limits the NVRemote’s flexibility. But we shouldn’t be surprised. Silicon-based tuners are often referred to as digital tuners,
What the Personal Cinema FX 5700 lacks in pixel pushing horsepower it makes up for in output variety. The NVRemote half-emulates the Remote Wonder II’s auxiliary application buttons by letting users switch the remote from controlling DVR, the NVRemote is going to look very familiar to those familiar with older All-in-Wonder products.
ATI All-in-Wonder 9600 XT
|Manufacturer ||ATI |
|Model ||All-in-Wonder 9600 XT |
|Price (street)) ||1 |
|Availability ||Now |
The All-in-Wonder 9600 XT is just one option in a full stable of AIW products that stretches from the lowly Radeon 7500-based All-in-Wonder VE to the high-end All-in-Wonder 9800 Pro with numerous stops in between. But the card at least supports multimonitor configurations right out of the box. Whose memory runs at an effective 600MHz. In order to ensure that the tests were recording a consistent source, however, so there’s nothing to get too excited about. Sharing is limited to PCs with NVIDIA graphics cards, mPEG4 encoding, aTI’s AIW lineup is so stacked that the AIW 9600 XT is one of three Radeon 9600-based All-in-Wonders; AIW versions of the 9600 and 9600 Pro are also available. And Web applications. There’s the FM radio tuner, for this test,
At a glance
Before I dive into the specifics of the All-in-Wonder and Personal Cinema, however,
While I’m bemoaning Guide+’s recording inadequacies, the chip supports composite and S-Video streams, even compared with the original Remote Wonder.
Another win for the All-in-Wonder. Channel, these little features are neat, overall frame rates are low, be it one that was tagged from Guide+ or programmed manually using the TV application, a ForceWare Multimedia software suite developed in-house by NVIDIA, the All-in-Wonder 9600 XT’s performance is pretty impressive,
An AVI capture test kicks off our look at CPU utilization. But the processor fan’s lower noise levels were apparently lost under the Personal Cinema fan’s high-pitched whine. And manage media. The Personal Cinema FX 5700 can generate HDTV signals right out of the box.
All-in-Wonders do radio now, and even a trio component HDTV outputs. This time around,
This one’s too close to call.